Pinwheel vs. Atomic vs. Argyle: How does our API stack up?
copy gray iconlinkedin graytwitter grey

Pinwheel vs. Atomic vs. Argyle: How does our API stack up?

May 4, 2022

Whether you’re a fintech or financial institution, payroll APIs are an important addition to your product. They allow you to make deposit switching easier, improve underwriting models, and branch off into new services like earned wage access. So partnering with a payroll API provider like Pinwheel, Atomic, or Argyle is bound to come up for consideration. ​

But selecting the right payroll data connectivity API can be tough. Many times we’ve heard from prospective clients that they can’t tell the difference between the three major payroll API providers. But the differences are there — and they’re not minor.

When shopping for a payroll API, it’s important to compare several key factors such as coverage, conversion, and security. And, of course, we can’t forget regulatory compliance since we’re dealing with private consumer data. With this in mind, here’s how Pinwheel’s API stacks up against others in the industry.

Payroll and income platform coverage

Coverage is the foundation of any payroll data connectivity API. Our clients can’t serve their customers if they can’t connect to their payroll or income platform. Pinwheel has coverage of over 80% of U.S. workers, spanning 1,500 payroll and income platforms, which is three times the industry average. We also cover 97% of the Fortune 1000, which employs 15-20% of all U.S. employees.

Our competitors lag behind in this aspect. Atomic covers 75% of U.S. workers and 450 payroll platforms, while Argyle also covers 75% of American workers with around 300 payroll and gig platforms.

Although we lead the way in terms of coverage, our team is constantly working to further expand it. Recently, we announced that we’d enabled connectivity to the top 20 time and attendance services (T&A) that 25 million American hourly workers use to log shifts. Connecting to T&A is crucial for enabling services such as earned wage access that allow employees instant access to their earnings.

Conversion rates

Financial service providers use payroll APIs to improve conversions, whether that means making a direct deposit switch or setting up a paycheck-linked loan. Pinwheel has faced off against other APIs in the industry, and we have a 100% win rate in head-to-heads against our competitors.

Our unrivaled conversion rates are a result of our seamless user flow or Link UX. Link shows users a list of the most popular payroll providers and employers to make it easy to sign up with minimal friction. Users can also rely on the search bar at the top of the screen to find their payroll provider.

We’ve also recently updated Link UX with a selection confirmation screen to eliminate any user confusion. For example, a user might select their primary bank instead of their employer or payroll platform. Before they confirm, a screen appears that asks them if they are an employee of the company they selected. If not, they can navigate back to find the correct one.

But we must also point out that conversion is a nuanced metric, and it should be evaluated at a more granular level. For instance, when it comes to direct deposit conversions, it’s best to measure direct deposit penetration growth — the percentage of users who decided to forward all or a portion of their salary into their account. One of Pinwheel’s neobank customers saw its direct deposits grow by 20% just one month after implementing our API. This metric is more meaningful when evaluating an API than blanket conversions because it has a direct impact on our clients’ business outcomes.

FCRA compliance

Consumer payroll data is sensitive and should be given every protection available under the law. That’s why Pinwheel is the only payroll data connectivity company that is a Consumer Reporting Agency (CRA). Our status as a CRA means our clients can use consumer permissioned data for credit decisions and remain compliant with the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA).

The FCRA regulates how third parties (like credit bureaus) can aggregate and sell consumer financial data. It defines the information that third parties can collect and who is allowed to see it. Under the FCRA, consumers can also request access to this data, which lets them verify that the information is correct. For example, if a consumer applies for a loan and is rejected because of poor credit, they have the right to request their credit report. Each FCRA violation (such as providing inaccurate or old information) carries a $100-$1,000 fine. But some violations have resulted in multi-million dollar penalties, making FCRA compliance a priority for every financial service provider.

Payroll data connectivity companies like Pinwheel, Atomic, and Argyle aggregate information that other companies use to approve consumers for credit products. Although we don’t make any credit decisions directly, if our data is bad, that could have an adverse effect on the consumer. As such, we should stand behind the quality of our data and be liable if it leads to bad outcomes — and being a CRA helps us do that.

Other companies in the payroll space simply advise their clients to comply with FCRA without offering them the tools to do so. Only Pinwheel has created legal and operational frameworks to make it easy for our clients to be FCRA compliant. We’ve also set up an FCRA end-user portal where consumers can access their data and, if necessary, file a dispute.

Pinwheel’s API is backed by a world-class team

The reason Pinwheel was able to build an API with superior coverage and data quality is our people. We sourced our team from some of the best companies in the industry, such as Plaid, so building API products is ingrained in our company’s DNA. That’s why we’re improving our data quality around the clock and have ecosystem partnerships in every banking vertical to help our clients reduce costs and decrease time to launch. And our uptime is 99.999%, even at the highest monthly volumes.

As the only payroll data connectivity company with a Chief Information Security Officer, our team has built a platform where security is a priority. We’ve implemented bank-level encryption protocols and have a SOC 2 Type II certification — the most extensive SOC credential. From security to regulatory compliance, we’ve developed a payroll API platform that checks all the boxes and is ready to propel financial services into the future.

Always stay up to date

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
View our Privacy Policy   ➔

Up next

How alternative credit data can benefit lenders

How alternative credit data can benefit lenders

Read more  ➔
Tech Spotlight: Implementing your first feature flag

Tech Spotlight: Implementing your first feature flag

Read more  ➔
Pinwheel Welcomes New Advisor, Ethan Yeh, to Advance Pinwheel’s Data Science Strategy

Pinwheel Welcomes New Advisor, Ethan Yeh, to Advance Pinwheel’s Data Science Strategy

Read more  ➔
Tech spotlight: Securing access control across internal services

Tech spotlight: Securing access control across internal services

Read more  ➔
The anatomy and potential of payroll data: Transforming complex data into insights

The anatomy and potential of payroll data: Transforming complex data into insights

Read more  ➔
Beyond the credit score: Propelling consumer finance into the future with income data

Beyond the credit score: Propelling consumer finance into the future with income data

Read more  ➔
Ayokunle (Ayo) Omojola joins Pinwheel’s Board of Directors

Ayokunle (Ayo) Omojola joins Pinwheel’s Board of Directors

Read more  ➔
Conquering conversion: Engineering practices developed to help customers

Conquering conversion: Engineering practices developed to help customers

Read more  ➔
Driving Customer Delight: From implementation and beyond

Driving Customer Delight: From implementation and beyond

Read more  ➔
Pinwheel Supports Open Finance Data Security Standard

Pinwheel Supports Open Finance Data Security Standard

Read more  ➔
How we design Pinwheel to solve real customer problems

How we design Pinwheel to solve real customer problems

Read more  ➔
What is consumer-permissioned data and what are its benefits?

What is consumer-permissioned data and what are its benefits?

Read more  ➔
How payroll data connectivity can help financial service providers in tumultuous market conditions

How payroll data connectivity can help financial service providers in tumultuous market conditions

Read more  ➔
Pinwheel now supports document uploads to supplement payroll data

Pinwheel now supports document uploads to supplement payroll data

Read more  ➔
Brian Karimi-Pashaki joins Pinwheel as Partnerships Lead

Brian Karimi-Pashaki joins Pinwheel as Partnerships Lead

Read more  ➔
Optimizing for conversion with smarter employer mappings

Optimizing for conversion with smarter employer mappings

Read more  ➔
What are super apps and how will they impact financial services?

What are super apps and how will they impact financial services?

Read more  ➔
Increase conversions and maximize share of wallet with Pinwheel's new UX update

Increase conversions and maximize share of wallet with Pinwheel's new UX update

Read more  ➔
Pinwheel announces support for taxes

Pinwheel announces support for taxes

Read more  ➔
Ryan Nier Joins Pinwheel as the Company’s first General Counsel

Ryan Nier Joins Pinwheel as the Company’s first General Counsel

Read more  ➔
The future of enabling earned wage access

The future of enabling earned wage access

Read more  ➔
Deliver earned wage access faster with Pinwheel Earnings Stream

Deliver earned wage access faster with Pinwheel Earnings Stream

Pinwheel Earnings Stream provides the necessary data and intelligence to reliably offer earned wage access (EWA) at scale.

Read more  ➔
Digital transformation in banking in 2022: What it means, trends & examples

Digital transformation in banking in 2022: What it means, trends & examples

Read more  ➔
June product release: Expanded connectivity to employers, a custom experience with Link API and more

June product release: Expanded connectivity to employers, a custom experience with Link API and more

Read more  ➔
Pinwheelie Spotlight: LaRena Iocco, Software Engineer

Pinwheelie Spotlight: LaRena Iocco, Software Engineer

Read more  ➔
Build fully custom experiences with Pinwheel’s Link API

Build fully custom experiences with Pinwheel’s Link API

Read more  ➔
Pinwheel expands connectivity to 1.5M employers

Pinwheel expands connectivity to 1.5M employers

Read more  ➔
Robert Reynolds joins Pinwheel as Head of Product

Robert Reynolds joins Pinwheel as Head of Product

Read more  ➔
Pinwheel obtains highest security certification in the industry

Pinwheel obtains highest security certification in the industry

Read more  ➔
Lauren Crossett becomes Pinwheel’s first Chief Revenue Officer

Lauren Crossett becomes Pinwheel’s first Chief Revenue Officer

Read more  ➔
Everything you should know about the role of APIs in banking

Everything you should know about the role of APIs in banking

Read more  ➔
Open finance: What is it and how does it impact financial services?

Open finance: What is it and how does it impact financial services?

Read more  ➔
How automated direct deposit switching benefits traditional banks

How automated direct deposit switching benefits traditional banks

Read more  ➔
Pinwheel Secure: Authentication optimized for market-leading conversion

Pinwheel Secure: Authentication optimized for market-leading conversion

Read more  ➔
Pinwheelie Spotlight: Elena Churilova, Software Engineer, Integrations

Pinwheelie Spotlight: Elena Churilova, Software Engineer, Integrations

Read more  ➔
May product release: Localization and downloadable pay stubs

May product release: Localization and downloadable pay stubs

Read more  ➔
How a payroll API can level up lenders and renters

How a payroll API can level up lenders and renters

Read more  ➔
The power of payroll APIs in consumer finance

The power of payroll APIs in consumer finance

Read more  ➔
Data Talks: Pinwheel’s Fortune 1000 coverage and top employer trends

Data Talks: Pinwheel’s Fortune 1000 coverage and top employer trends

Read more  ➔
April product release: Enabling connectivity to time and attendance data for 25M US workers

April product release: Enabling connectivity to time and attendance data for 25M US workers

Read more  ➔
Tech spotlight: Increasing engineering momentum at a systems level

Tech spotlight: Increasing engineering momentum at a systems level

Read more  ➔
How crypto exchanges can turn direct deposits into a fiat onramp

How crypto exchanges can turn direct deposits into a fiat onramp

Read more  ➔
March product release: Time and attendance coverage and Pinwheel's new online home

March product release: Time and attendance coverage and Pinwheel's new online home

Read more  ➔
Pinwheelie spotlight: Arianna Gelwicks, Tech Recruiting

Pinwheelie spotlight: Arianna Gelwicks, Tech Recruiting

Read more  ➔
What is payroll data and how it benefits proptech companies

What is payroll data and how it benefits proptech companies

Read more  ➔
Earned wage access: What is it and why does it matter?

Earned wage access: What is it and why does it matter?

Read more  ➔
How fintech APIs are transforming financial services

How fintech APIs are transforming financial services

Read more  ➔
Webinar: Unleash growth with income and payroll APIs

Webinar: Unleash growth with income and payroll APIs

Read more  ➔
February product release: Updated Link UX and data quality

February product release: Updated Link UX and data quality

Read more  ➔
Why a direct deposit switching API is a must-have for banks and neobanks

Why a direct deposit switching API is a must-have for banks and neobanks

Read more  ➔
Tech spotlight: Floating footer with React functional components

Tech spotlight: Floating footer with React functional components

Read more  ➔
Pinwheelie spotlight: Hale Ahangi, People Operations Lead

Pinwheelie spotlight: Hale Ahangi, People Operations Lead

Read more  ➔
Shift from a vicious to virtuous cycle: The foundation for a fairer financial system

Shift from a vicious to virtuous cycle: The foundation for a fairer financial system

Read more  ➔
January product release: Recurring access to income & employment

January product release: Recurring access to income & employment

Read more  ➔
Pinwheel’s Series B and our path towards a fairer financial future

Pinwheel’s Series B and our path towards a fairer financial future

We're excited to share that we have raised a $50M Series B funding round led by GGV Capital with participation from many others.

Read more  ➔
Pinwheelie spotlight: Devin DeCaro-Brown, Product Manager

Pinwheelie spotlight: Devin DeCaro-Brown, Product Manager

Read more  ➔
Tech spotlight: How to implement async requests in your Python code

Tech spotlight: How to implement async requests in your Python code

Read more  ➔
2021 recap and product update: An amazing year for Pinwheel

2021 recap and product update: An amazing year for Pinwheel

Read more  ➔
Charles Tsang joins Pinwheel as Head of Marketing

Charles Tsang joins Pinwheel as Head of Marketing

Read more  ➔
Pinwheelie spotlight: Octavio Roscioli, Senior Software Engineer

Pinwheelie spotlight: Octavio Roscioli, Senior Software Engineer

Read more  ➔
November product release: Beta launch of income & employment monitoring

November product release: Beta launch of income & employment monitoring

Read more  ➔
How can payroll data help with one’s financial picture?

How can payroll data help with one’s financial picture?

Read more  ➔
Pinwheelie spotlight: Caroline Lo, Software Engineer

Pinwheelie spotlight: Caroline Lo, Software Engineer

Read more  ➔
2021 company onsite: Bringing Pinwheelies together

2021 company onsite: Bringing Pinwheelies together

Read more  ➔
October product release: Beta launch of direct deposit allocation monitoring

October product release: Beta launch of direct deposit allocation monitoring

Read more  ➔
Why payroll data access is inevitable on your product roadmap

Why payroll data access is inevitable on your product roadmap

Read more  ➔
Security spotlight: SOC 2 compliance

Security spotlight: SOC 2 compliance

Read more  ➔
Jeff Hudesman joins Pinwheel as Chief Information Security Officer

Jeff Hudesman joins Pinwheel as Chief Information Security Officer

Read more  ➔
Welcoming John Whitfield, VP of Engineering

Welcoming John Whitfield, VP of Engineering

Read more  ➔
Announcing Pinwheel’s FCRA Compliance

Announcing Pinwheel’s FCRA Compliance

Read more  ➔
Pinwheel's statement on Section 1033

Pinwheel's statement on Section 1033

Read more  ➔
Pinwheel raises $20M Series A

Pinwheel raises $20M Series A

Read more  ➔
If I were a fintech founder

If I were a fintech founder

Read more  ➔
Pinwheelie spotlight: Phil Jen, Director of Product

Pinwheelie spotlight: Phil Jen, Director of Product

Read more  ➔
Celebrating women's history month with Sasha Pilch

Celebrating women's history month with Sasha Pilch

Read more  ➔
Tech spotlight: How we re-launched our API docs

Tech spotlight: How we re-launched our API docs

Read more  ➔
Why I chose Pinwheel: Payroll APIs as the next frontier

Why I chose Pinwheel: Payroll APIs as the next frontier

Read more  ➔
Lunch and learn with Nik Milanović

Lunch and learn with Nik Milanović

Read more  ➔
Pinwheelie spotlight: David Daudelin, Senior Front End Engineer

Pinwheelie spotlight: David Daudelin, Senior Front End Engineer

Read more  ➔
The missing link

The missing link

Read more  ➔
Introducing Pinwheel, the API for payroll

Introducing Pinwheel, the API for payroll

Read more  ➔